What if Star Wars: Episode IX Was Different?

The highly anticipated conclusion to the Skywalker Saga, Star Wars: Episode IX, was expected to bring the iconic franchise full circle with a satisfying conclusion to the story that had captivated generations of fans. However, the actual release of Star Wars: Episode IX (along with its predecessor, The Last Jedi) left some fans disappointed. The film was heavily criticized for its plot and pacing, its mishandling of beloved characters, and its overall lack of coherence.

With so much to be desired, it’s interesting to consider how Episode IX could have been different if it had been handled differently. Here are three possible ways that Episode IX’s script and plot could have been changed for a much more satisfying conclusion to the Star Wars saga.

A More Satisfying Character Arc For Kylo Ren

From the very beginning of the sequel trilogy, Kylo Ren had all the makings of an excellent villain: a powerful Sith wielder of the Force, a determined and ruthless opponent, and a complicated relationship with his family. However, by the time Episode IX rolled around, Kylo Ren had devolved into a petulant and whiny villain, seemingly devoid of any real danger.

If Episode IX had been tweaked slightly, Kylo Ren could have been given an ending that more adequately recognizes his journey. This could have included the revelation of hidden wounds from his past, a more sympathetic voice, and a deeper understanding of the consequences of his actions. Such an ending could have created a villain who, despite his flaws, was still a multi-faceted, complex character worthy of fear and respect.

A Change of Plot To Give a More Fitting Ending to the Skywalker Saga

Episode IX also faced criticism for its rushed and lazy plot, which felt like a half-hearted attempt to tie up loose ends. Many fans of the franchise felt unsatisfied with the way their beloved characters were treated, with their arcs unsatisfyingly rushed to their conclusions.

If the plot of Episode IX had been changed to focus more on character development and less on convenient plot twists, then the end of the Skywalker saga could have felt more fitting. This could have included separate story arcs for Leia and Luke, delving deeper into their respective struggles and allowing them momentous conclusions. Luke could have made a more proactive choice, and Leia’s could involve a heartfelt goodbye with her son. The result would have been a more meaningful and powerful conclusion to the saga.

A More Compelling Villain To Prepare For Future Films

One of the biggest criticisms leveled at Episode IX was the underwhelming reveal of Emperor Palpatine as the main villain. While Palpatine has always been a major antagonist in previous episodes, fans felt that his sudden resurrection lacked depth and didn’t give enough set-up for the ultimate outcome or prepare for any possible future Star Wars films.

If this had been changed, a stronger and more logical villain could have been introduced. This could have involved an antagonist who better fit the story and had more concrete motivations, as well as the groundwork for future films. Such a character could have had be far-reaching implications in the galaxy, captivating audiences and creating potential spin-offs and sequels.

Regardless of which direction was chosen for Episode IX, one thing is for sure; Star Wars will always remain an iconic cinematic journey that unites generations of viewers. As fans continue to dream up different versions of Episode IX, they can take comfort in the fact that this famous saga will never really end.